Why does putting an apple in your brown sugar keep the sugar soft?
Storing an apple with your brown sugar will help keep your sugar soft. (Photo: Shala Howell)
This fall, The Seven-Year-Old and I went apple picking at Radke Orchards in Indiana. While there, I picked up a little paperback book of Old Fashioned Apple Recipes (Bear Wallow Books, 1980) on the principle that there are only so many apple pies one family can be expected to eat. Nestled among the recipes for Apple Corn Bread, Apple Fritters, Apple-Sweet Potato Bakes, and Honey Apple Cake, I found this tip:
“An apple in your brown sugar container will help to keep the sugar moist.”
I was dubious. After all, I’ve been taken in by these sorts of claims before. Brown Sugar Bears, hermetically sealed containers, slices of bread … none of it works for me. The brown sugar ALWAYS hardens up. Since I’ve given up on spending money and switched to storing my open sugar bags in gallon-sized Ziplocs on the At-Least-This-Will-Keep-the-Mice-Out principle, the hardening usually happens within 24 hours.
Still, I had an apple or two to spare, so I decided to give it a try.
Something about plopping the apple directly into the brown sugar seemed a bit unsavory, so I found a gallon-sized Ziploc, dropped an opened bag of brown sugar into it, added one of my less yummy-looking apples, and sealed the whole thing up tight.
The next morning, when I pulled it out to make oatmeal, the brown sugar was still soft. Interesting, given my track record, but not yet impressive.
Impressive is pulling the Ziploc out all these weeks later and finding the brown sugar still as soft as the day I first stored it.
Impressive is the fact that I now expect to find soft, pliable brown sugar in my pantry.
So why does putting an apple in the bag work when all those commercial approaches have failed?
Apparently, the brown sugar sucks up the moisture from the apple, and that added moisture keeps the sugar soft. This article says you can just use apple slices, but by the time I found it, I had already plopped an entire apple into the bag. Two months later, the apple is still fine, and the brown sugar still fresh. I’m not entirely sure that a mere slice would have lasted this long.
My old-fashioned cookbook also claims that storing an apple with your potatoes will help keep them from sprouting. I am so trying that.
Related Links:
- Pantry Problem Solving: 5 ways to keep brown sugar soft (the kitchn)
- Breakfast at Caterpickles (Caterpickles)
- Classic Caterpickles: Breakfast at Caterpickles II (Caterpickles)
CATERPICKLES 
2 Responses to “Why does putting an apple in your brown sugar keep the sugar soft?”
im thinking you don’t know the answer to my question 😭 is brown sugar safe to use if it had an apple in it for months and when I went to use it the apple was really wilted and the sugar around it was white!!!!?
LikeLike
Hi. No I’m sorry I don’t know the answer to that question. I didn’t store my apple directly touching my sugar bc I was afraid that the apple would spoil and ruin the sugar as well. I have always kept a ziploc barrier between them.
For what it’s worth, I’ve stopped using apples entirely and just store the brown sugar in a ziploc, pressing out all of the air each time I close it and it’s worked just as well as the apples ever did.
I’m sorry about your sugar. I wish I knew the answer to whether it’s safe but I don’t. I probably would toss/compost it and buy a new bag.
LikeLike