“Did any of the Presidents not like toys?”
It’s nearing the end of the year, so I’m in a clear-out-the-old-backlog-of-questions sort of mood.
Back when The Eight-Year-Old was only five, we spent a lovely afternoon building a village for her toy dinosaurs out of Lincoln logs. After carefully installing a sunlight in the roof of her sauropod stable, The (then) Five-Year-Old asked:
“Mommyo, did any of the Presidents not like toys?”
Mommyo: “I’m sure they all played with toys as kids.”
The (then) Five-Year-Old: “No. I’m talking about grown-ups. Grown-up Presidents who played with toys.”
Mommyo: “Well, President Obama plays fetch with his dog.”
The (then) Five-Year-Old: “Dog toys don’t count, Mommyo. I’m talking about real toys.”
Mommyo: “Hmm. Well, most parents play with their kids at some point, and that often involves toys. Can we assume that Presidents with kids played with toys?”
The (then) Five-Year-Old, graciously: “Yes.”
Mommyo: “Well, President Obama’s kids are still young enough to play with toys. I don’t think President Bush’s were when he was in office, though.”
The (then) Five-Year-Old: “I’m ok with the toy-playing happening anytime after he was an adult.”
Mommyo: “So not just while he was President?”
The (then) Five-Year-Old: “That’s right.”
Mommyo: “So can we assume that any President who had kids played with kid toys as an adult?”
The (then) Five-Year-Old: “Yep.”
At last! A question I knew how to Google! Which U.S. Presidents had kids? Better, which ones didn’t, because those would be the ones who most likely didn’t play with toys.
I dutifully recorded the question (and the rather lengthy conversation that refined it in my Caterpickles Future Questions Log), and then spent the next three years industriously not asking Google anything about it.
Whew. That was hard work.
But I’m glad I did it, because while I was busy ignoring The (then) Five-Year-Old’s question, Mona Chalabi at FiveThirtyEightPolitics was knee-deep into the requisite genealogical research.
James K. Polk was the only U.S. President (so far) to not have kids
According to Chalabi, all but one of the U.S. Presidents had children and/or grandchildren by the time they were sworn into office. James K. Polk, who served from 1845-1849, was the only childless President.
Which by The (then) Five-Year-Old’s criteria meant that President Polk was the only U.S. President who didn’t like toys as an adult.
I dutifully reported that fact to The (now) Eight-Year-Old while taking her to school last Wednesday morning.
Naturally she didn’t remember asking the question. But that’s ok. I’m used to that.
When she was all caught up, The Eight-Year-Old wrote off my conclusion deftly: “Just because he didn’t have kids doesn’t mean anything, Mommyo. He might have liked to play games with his friends. I mean, look at Daddyo and Uncle Phil.”
So did Polk like to play any games? Even ones that don’t feature kids?
Mommyo, doubtfully: “I don’t know, The Eight-Year-Old. Everything I’ve read implies that President Polk was a pretty severe sort of person. Not really the type to play games. He sounds like a more work, less play type.”
The Eight-Year-Old, determinedly: “But he still might have liked to play card games. See if he did that.”
Mommyo, consulting her iPhone: “Huh. It says here that his wife, Sarah Polk, was a devout Presbyterian and banned dancing, card playing, and alcohol from the White House.”
The Eight-Year-Old, decidedly: “That’s so mean!…
“Mommyo, do you think Polk played card games outside of the White House?”
Mommyo: “He would have had to, wouldn’t he? Still, I think it’s pretty clear that if there had been a President who didn’t like to…”
The Eight-Year-Old, interruptingly: “You mean ‘wasn’t allowed to.’ We still don’t know whether he liked to or not.”
Mommyo, more accurately: “Right. If there had been a President who didn’t play with toys, it would have been James Polk.”
The Eight-Year-Old, sadly: “Yeah, poor guy.”
- “All the President’s Grandchildren” (FiveThirtyEightPolitics)
- James K Polk (Encyclopedia Britannica)
- 20 Pictures of US Presidents Playing Sports (Bleacher Report)
- Incredible Vintage Pictures of Presidents Playing Sports (BusinessInsider)
4 Responses to ““Did any of the Presidents not like toys?””
But he did inspire a rather fun song by They Might Be Giants: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H9SvJMZs5Rs
Awesome! Thanks for sharing!
[…] “Did any of the Presidents not like toys?” (Caterpickles) […]
[…] it was a little surprising in the moment to have my question deferred so adroitly. But then again, I’ve been deferring her questions to answer later pretty much all of her life, so at least I know how she learned […]