“How did they make old-timey ice cream?”

Poster for the Congregational Church of Needham’s 1890 Strawberry Festival. (Image: Danielle Jurdan)

I continue to be fascinated by this Strawberry Festival poster, which I found in the archives room of my church a few months ago. As does The Five-Year-Old, who after hearing my explanation of why the soaring price of ice in 1890 could jeopardize an entire festival, asked, “How did they make old-timey ice cream, Mommyo?”

My copy of The Original Fannie Farmer 1896 Cookbook includes several recipes for ice cream, but sadly no instructions for how one would actually go about freezing it. Marion Harland etal’s New England Cook Book from 1905 also includes lots of recipes, but no actual instructions on process.

Thank goodness for suite101.com. Their article on 1890-1920 Ice Cream Pudding Recipes is quite detailed on this point. Basically, to make homemade ice cream back in 1890, you would take today’s process and add a bunch of manual labor.

In other words:

  1. Prepare fruit, nuts, and other ice cream mix-ins, and set aside.
  2. Mix the liquid ingredients for the ice cream together in an earthenware jar.
  3. Crush a bunch of ice and add salt to it. (1 part salt to 3 parts ice)
  4. Put the ice and salt in a basin with plenty of room to hold the ice as well as your earthenware jar.
  5. Cover the jar with a piece of cloth with a slit in it or with several layers of thick grease-proof paper. Carefully insert an egg beater through the slit in the cloth and/or paper.
  6. Put the jar in the basin with the ice and salt. Let it sit for five minutes, then turn the crank on the egg beater slowly and steadily for a few minutes. Freeze to a mush.
  7. Add mashed fruit, nuts and other flavorings when the mixture is half-frozen.
  8. Keep stirring, increasing your speed steadily until the mixture freezes completely.
  9. Once frozen, let the ice cream sit in the jar or a mold for at least an hour to “ripen.”

Suite101 includes a number of ice cream recipes, in case you want to try this at home. They sound interesting, but frankly I doubt our church’s Friendly Society would have served Irish Moss ice cream at a Strawberry Festival in 1890. They were much more likely to use something like these basic Ice Cream recipes from my 1896 Fanny Farmer:

Advertisement for the 1890s Gem Freezer: “The Best in the World” (Image via stilltherllbemore, who has put the postcard up for sale on ebay.)

Vanilla Ice Cream I (Philadelphia)

  • 1 quart thin cream
  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 1 1/2 tablespoons vanilla

Mix ingredients and freeze.

Strawberry Ice Cream

  • 3 pints thin cream
  • 2 boxes strawberries
  • 1 3/4 cups sugar
  • 2 cups milk
  • 1 1/2 tablespoons arrowroot

Wash and hull berries, sprinkle with sugar, let stand one hour, mash and rub through strainer. Scald one and one-half cups milk; dilute arrowroot with remaining milk, add to hot milk, and cook ten minutes in double boiler; cool, add cream, freeze to a mush, add fruit and finish freezing.

Let me know if you do try this at home. I’d love to know how it turns out.

BTW: Although Agnes Marshall (1855-1905) included a recipe for an edible ice cream cone in her 1888 Mrs A. B. Marshall’s Cookery Book, ice cream cones didn’t become widely available until some time after the 1904 St. Louis World’s Fair. So for a truly authentic recreation, you’ll need to serve your 1890s-style ice cream in a bowl.

Related Links:

(Cross-posted at my historical blog, Once Upon a Time in Needham.)

About Shala Howell

I write about wildly curious kids, rabbits who hunt dragons, and 1880s Boston. When I’m not scratching my head over pesky characters who refuse to do things how I want them done or dreaming of my next book (which will of course be much easier to write than the current one), I blog about life with a very curious Ten-Year-Old at Caterpickles.com, muse about books and the writing life at BostonWriters.blog, or tweet about books, writing, science, & things that make me smile at @shalahowell.
This entry was posted in Can we do that sometime? and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to “How did they make old-timey ice cream?”

  1. Pingback: Wordless Wednesday: Crescent Ridge Dairy Farm in Sharon, Massachusetts | CATERPICKLES

  2. Pingback: “How did they make old-timey ketchup?” A Caterpickles Investigative Report, Part Two: The Cooking | CATERPICKLES

  3. Pingback: “How did they make old-timey ketchup?”: A Caterpickles Investigative Report, Part Three | CATERPICKLES

  4. Pingback: “Mommyo, can we have an old-timey Thanksgiving?” | CATERPICKLES

What are you thinking?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s